Creepy blogger!
I have to confess to being a closet blogger. That is, I personally have used blogs to organize and collect things I’ve done and learned online, but I admit to not using them that often in my classes. My first blog was created using Blogger in 2009, but its lack of ability to make pages within the blog led me to make a new blog for every online course or tool I learned in preparation for starting MET. This soon got unwieldy!
When I started MET and found we had to have an ongoing e-portfolio, I was impressed with WordPress’s templates, appearance, and pagination, so have used it to document course assignments, and to keep a running reflection in the home page blog. I haven’t made either blog public, and find that I am a “creeper”; I read other people’s blogs, but don’t encourage two-way participation in my own creations.
In my classes, I use Blogger in two ways. First, whenever we have a guest speaker or see a longer video that doesn’t allow time for an in-class assignment, I have the students comment on the video and on each others’ comments based on a set of open-ended criteria. I also post replacement media for absent students, who can then access it from home. However, I find that, at least with my grade 9 students, they do not readily comment “back & forth” in this educational setting, and I don’t know if it’s because of the linear way Blogger is organized or their lack of interest in the topics (!).
The second way I use blogs is when reading a novel with the class. We have students post personal responses to journal questions in the class blog. However, I have yet to find a blog platform that doesn’t end up looking somewhat overwhelming, especially to struggling readers and students with low motivation. I am hoping to find a less visually chaotic format in the links Group 7 has posted. I like blogs that have a moderator function that allows previewing of comments before posting is allowed, as well as those that are easy to set up in terms of members, i.e. ones that don’t require remembering a password or requiring an email address, and that can be set up in batches.
General impressions of blogging platforms:
Drupal:
- I was going to try it, but the need to install base system files and modules to my computer put me off right away. I want a cloud-based application, especially since our work computers are locked by the IT department at school.
Edublog:
- This looks worth a try, especially with its webpage-like format and educational focus.
- I could see having groups or the whole class create a digital newspaper this way, instead of cutting and pasting.
Loudblog:
- I could see using this personally to post podcasts and mp3’s with my other weird music collecting friends (post-MET, once I have a life again
- 8-0)
Tumblr:
- This looks very similar to Posterous. Has anyone used both?
I hope to improve upon my lackluster blog performance after this week’s experience, and am motivated to explore further..
BTW, great job with the interactivity in your WordPress, Group 7!
KJ
Posted in: Week 07: Blogs
Everton Walker 1:40 pm on October 18, 2011 Permalink | Log in to Reply
Karen,
Nice work! I also like blogs that allow me to be in control. As a result, students think about what they plan to post as it will be deleted or not published if guidelines are not followed. I have also noticed that if the blog is not frequently updated and social media features integrated, students will show little or no interest in it.
Everton
Deb Kim 8:31 pm on October 18, 2011 Permalink | Log in to Reply
Karen and Everton,
I agree with you that I also like blogs that I can control.
I agree with you Karen that Blogger Dashboard was much harder to use compared to WordPress. I’ve been using WP for my classes since 2 years ago and students like how I’ve set up the blog.
Everton, you are right that students would not be interested if a blog is not updated frequently.
Deb
Juliana 4:28 pm on October 18, 2011 Permalink | Log in to Reply
Hi Karen,
Thanks for the compliment! And I agree that sometimes blogs can look a little overwhelming. When there are long pages of text it can definitely get overwhelming and sometimes the page options of WordPress can decrease the overwhelming feeling.
I agree with you about Drupal and necessity of downloading everything to your computer. In a school system where you have to meet with IT requirements, a system like Drupal can be very cumbersome. I get the feeling that if you were looking at blogs like a venture that was targetted for the K-12 environment, you would prefer to see a cloud-based system. Is there anything else that you would like to see in blogging platforms to make them even better for your applications?
Juliana.
Karen Jones 5:49 pm on October 18, 2011 Permalink | Log in to Reply
Hi Juliana,
I am glad for this opportunity to investigate different blogging platforms, and find myself preferring the ones that start to look more like multimedia webpages, i.e. Edublog and Posterous. I think the ability to impose privacy limits for class- or educational-only access is important in all web applications that are used for teaching, although that could be seen to impede a real community of learning, I guess. There is a definite approach to encouraging student participation in blogs, as Everton points out above, and I think it’s a case of me needing to play around a bit more in order to tailor the medium to my students’ learning styles and preferences.
Thanks!
KJ
Juliana 4:54 pm on October 19, 2011 Permalink | Log in to Reply
Hi Karen,
Thank you for your post. I think in this day and age, it will be very important to have some sort of security features on blogs. I think that is a definite drawback for some of the free ones out there.
You also spoke of encouraging participation in blogs. What challenges have you seen with respect to participation?
Juliana.
bcourey 7:38 pm on October 18, 2011 Permalink | Log in to Reply
I agree with you that in the MET program we can be overwhelmed with the multitude of requests to create a blog for our eportfolio, but do you see the benefit for students to do the same thing? and would they too be overwhelmed if various teachers requested the same assignment? I am glad you are exploring the various platforms that are available for blogging – our question will be, is there a tool that would do an even better job?
ifeoma 8:40 pm on October 18, 2011 Permalink | Log in to Reply
Hi Karen,
It sounds like your class is the digital village for the digital natives of today. Good job! I enjoyed reading your post! particularly because I found a lot of things there that I could relate to myself, e.g. reading other peoples blog and not making mine public. I find that the way you use blogs in your classroom resonates with my ideas about using blogs in the classroom. I am not a teacher but I completely agree with having Moderator rights to review posts before they are published. I like that feature because I think it will make life easier for both teacher and students in preventing inappropriate comments.
Ifeoma